The 1 Best Pumpkin Patches in Carthage, NY
Ranked by rating and review volume. Updated for the 2026 season — always confirm hours with the farm before you drive out.
-
ELMER CREEK FARM
ELMER CREEK FARM takes the top spot, rated 4.8 out of 5 from 10 reviews.
33257 County Rd 163, 13619
Visiting a pumpkin patch near Carthage
Farms around Carthage follow the same rhythm as the rest of New York: gates open in the second half of September, the busiest weekends fall in mid-October, and most patches close within a few days of Halloween. Weekday mornings are consistently the quietest time to go.
Call ahead if it has rained recently. Field access and wagon rides are the first things a farm closes when the ground is soft, and that decision is usually made the morning of.
Nearby towns in New York
Aquebogue 1
Bayside 1
Brockport 1
Brooklyn 1
CASTLETON 1
Calverton 1
Camden 1
Cazenovia 1
Churchville 1
Cicero 1
Clarence 1
Clinton 1
Dix Hills 1
Dundee 1
East Amherst 1
Elma 1
Elmira 2
Esperance 1
Fly Creek 1
Goshen 1
Granite Springs 1
Granville 1
Greene 1
Greenwich 1
Hamden 1
Huntington 1
Jamesport 1
Jamestown 1
Kerhonkson 1
Macedon 1
Manlius 1
Marcellus 1
Marietta 1
Massena 1
Melville 1
Middletown 1
Mt Upton 1
Newark Valley 1
North Branch 1
North Collins 1
North Salem 1
North Tonawanda 1
Ovid 1
Parish 2
Pawling 1
Penfield 2
Penn Yan 1
Plattsburgh 1
Potsdam 1
Richfield Springs 3
Rochester 1
Rushville 1
Sackets Harbor 1
Saratoga Springs 2
Sauquoit 1
Schaghticoke 1
Seneca Falls 1
Smithville Flats 1
Stanley 1
Staten Island 1
Syracuse 1
Tivoli 1
Troy 1
Trumansburg 1
Victor 1
Wading River 1
Warwick 1
Waterloo 1
Weedsport 1